One of the great things about buying a “Greatest Hits Compilation” of your favourite music artist (at least for me) is the “re-mix version” or “unreleased track” or “free b-side songs” that are usually added on as a bonus. Unfortunately, this book is an “Emergent Greatest Hits” book with no bonus tracks. I actually had to look at the publishing date half way through the book to see if this was an old release. That is the greatest flaw of this book. The emergents claims that they are a conversant type of group – well it’s time for them to change the topic.
Does this seem harsh? Yes maybe, but for a book published in 2008, I did not expect to read the same stuff I did 8 years ago.
But there was some stuff I did like about the book. And of course some more things I didn’t. So, let’s change momentum here and bring out the positives.
My thinking in buying this book was this: I am a pastor who deals with people who feel let down or have given up on Christianity. And this book does reach out of those type of people… and I will definitely pass this book on to them.
Here are a few pastoral highlights.
Highlight #1 – faith is not a system of beliefs but a relationship
Highlight #2 – meeting physical needs is directly connected to spiritual needs (holistic)
Highlight #3 – sin management vs. story involvement (read the book for definitions)
As a pastor, I can use this stuff, and I really think people who are struggling could use it too.
Here are a few pastoral lowlights.
Lowlight #1 – Pagitt spends a chapter on deconstructing “systematic theology”, and yet uses that same system to make his case for holistic living.
Lowlight #2 – He tends to say that the bibles narrative is “holistic”. He uses the word “integrated” to describe the main theme of the bible. Wright would strongly disagree (and so would I)
Lowlight #3 - Pagitt goes nowhere with this book. Great, it’s okay to practice yoga and write books in coffee shops, but what was the point? Maybe he did this so he can write another book about the same stuff. (sorry for my sarcasm)
My thinking is that this book was written for the person searching. Well, if there is someone searching the used book shelf, they can buy my copy. Again, sorry for the sarcasm. Read it and judge for yourself. I have to admit though, I was reading Wright’s “Justification” at the same time – night and day, night and day.